Old TV's are Trouble for the Environment

Old TVs cause new problems

RECYCLE IT RIGHT

Activists would be just as happy if Americans would keep their old TVs as plant stands for a few years until better recycling programs are in place. But what if the garage is full and the closets are stuffed? Ask whether the store where you bought a new TV will take the old one. Many do for free, others for a small fee. Or find a nearby recycling program:

• The EPA has a list of recyclers.

• Earth 911 is ZIP-code searchable for recycling options.

• The National Recycling Coalition has links for every state.

• At e-Stewards, find recyclers who have signed the e-Steward pledge, a certification program that is today's highest standard of recycling.

"The rule of thumb is: It's nasty stuff, don't smash it, don't break it and don't dispose of it at the curb," says Robert Houghton of Redemtech.
Batteries are among the electronic waste processed at Universal Waste Management.
Enlarge By Martin E. Klimek, for USA TODAY
Batteries are among the electronic waste processed at Universal Waste Management.

THE REAL COST OF RECYCLING

What a 66-pound, 19-inch TV set would cost a recycler without state subsidies:
Revenue
Sale of precious metals and other recyclable material +$3.96
Costs
Recycling TV tube and screen glass -$4.80
Labor -$4.16
Shipping -$0.99
Net -$5.99

Source: Redemtech



By Elizabeth Weise, USA TODAY
EL CERRITO, Calif. — When the hatch popped open on Louis Cornelius' SUV, there were four TVs piled up in the back, all destined for recycling. "My wife wanted to be up to date on the electronics," he says.

Sumiko Flodin's 35-year-old TV "still works," but she bought a new 19-inch set at Best Buy and wanted to empty out her living room. "I don't like the idea of having all this stuff hanging around."

When Virginia Ritchie decided to clear out her old TVs, she loaded up the big one that didn't work anymore, "and then I found three TVs in the basement to get rid of."



For each of them, and most of the 300 or so people who came to an "electronic waste recycling event" on a chilly Saturday here, the motivation was simple: cleaning up. But for the Environmental Protection Agency and activists worried about soil, water and air pollution, it's more complicated.
FIND MORE STORIES IN: United States | Congress | Mexico | New York City | Oakland | TVs | Environmental Protection Agency | Government Accountability Office | Best Buy | Kyle | Cherry | Recovery | El Cerrito

Televisions carelessly disposed of can be toxic to the environment. A huge backlog of unused old ones (99.1 million, the EPA says) is sitting around in people's homes.

And later this year — either on Feb. 17 or on June 12 if Congress passes a delay — the USA will switch from analog to digital TV transmission. The number of unwanted TVs will go even higher as consumers upgrade to sets capable of receiving high-definition broadcasts.

Though a TV set is benign in the living room, it's not when it is broken up to reach the reusable materials inside. There's a lot of lead, a bit of barium, cadmium, chromium, traces of gold and even mercury in the lamps on some flat screens.

The best way to deal with them is not to throw them away at all but to keep using them, says John Cross of EPA's Office of Resource Conservation and Recovery. Buying a converter box or getting cable or satellite TV will keep a TV useful for years. But if TVs are discarded, the federal agency wants to make sure the materials in them are recycled.

The problem, according to a Government Accountability Office report last year, is that the EPA's "enforcement is lacking." That has left most of the regulatory work up to the states, only some of which license and audit recycling companies.

The GAO report found that although some electronics are handled responsibly, "a substantial quantity ends up in countries where disposal practices are unsafe to workers and dangerous to the environment." Barbara Kyle of the San Francisco-based Electronics TakeBack Coalition puts that quantity at close to 90%.

EPA environmental scientist Robert Tonetti says it's not that bad: "There are hundreds of honorable recyclers in the United States, and some scoundrels."

Taking the set apart

Under EPA rules, cathode-ray tube TVs — anything that's not flat screen — aren't supposed to be put into landfills, but households are exempt. It's also illegal to export them for recycling unless the destination country agrees and the EPA has been notified. But the GAO found that recycling companies routinely circumvent the rule.

Six states have passed laws making it illegal to throw a TV away, and another five are expected to do so in 2010, Kyle says. Eighteen states, as well as New York City, have ordered electronic recycling programs. But "not all the laws include televisions, which in the year of digital conversion is unfortunate," Kyle says.

Jacob Cherry, a third-generation recycler and CEO of Universal Waste Management, the Oakland company that organized the collection event, says he has seen "people just putting their television in a big black plastic bag so they wouldn't get caught."